Row breaks out over antivirus response times

A boast by F-Secure that it can counter new infections more quickly than any other antivirus firm has provoked an angry response from rival vendors. 

The row was sparked when a senior F-Secure executive told vnunet.com about the firm's ability to beat its competitors "easily".

"Symantec's figure is somewhere around nine hours. McAfee's is around 10 hours. So we are beating them easily, we are beating the big boys hands down," claimed F-Secure's chief research officer Mikko Hyppönen at a recent briefing.

However, McAfee responded angrily to the claims, describing them as " mischievous".
"Mikko Hyppönen is certainly picking and choosing his battles, and the figures he is quoting are from specific threats," Nick Bowman, a spokesman at McAfee, told vnunet.com.

"Some of those threats McAfee did not classify as medium risk or high risk and therefore didn't release any emergency DATs for them."

Hyppönen claimed that F-Secure's average reaction time to a virus is just two hours and 37 minutes.

"The average reaction time we have as clocked by the University of Magdeburg in Germany, Andreas Marx and his team, is two hours and 37 minutes. That's from the moment a new virus is found to the moment we are protecting our customers," he said.

Bowman begged to differ, however. "That's not specifically true. If F-Secure doesn't receive a sample of a threat until 24 hours after McAfee receives a copy, does that mean that the virus is not discovered until F-Secure receives the copy?" he said.

"For instance, McAfee and Symantec detect certain families of viruses without actually needing to put out an extra DAT file.

"If we were all at that same level Hyppönen would have a case, but he's just picking and choosing things where we may well have protected customers in any case without having to release anything at all. It's a bit mischievous, really. "

VIDEO: Mikko Hyppönen discusses the latest threats

See also:

Virus alerts 'as bad as spam'

Not so, says antivirus vendor  03 Apr 2006

McAfee virus update wreaks havoc

Update quarantines or deletes legitimate system files  14 Mar 2006

Netsky still top of the virus charts

February a quieter month overall as more users update definitions  02 Mar 2006

British business picks up on patching

But still slow on antivirus signatures, finds DTI survey  01 Mar 2006

Sophos sees OS X virus ghosts

Anti-virus software mistakes real applications for pests, breaks systems  22 Feb 2006

Like this story? Spread the news by clicking below:

 del.icio.us     Digg this     reddit!