Analysts question BlackBerry patent workaround

RIM's patent workaround unveiled last week is not the silver bullet that the BlackBerry maker claims it to be, analyst firm Current Analysis has warned. 

"The workaround could accomplish nothing if Judge Spenser demands that the BlackBerry service be shut off, even if RIM implements this workaround smoothly, " wrote analysts Avi Greengart and Kathryn Weldon.

"And NTP may sue, claiming that the workaround does, in fact, violate NTP's patents. At that point, the judge could demand that the workaround be terminated as well."

The Current Analysis report praised RIM for soothing concerns with users about a possible interruption to its service. The software could also allow the company to focus more on its business without being distracted by the lawsuit.

RIM unveiled a workaround last week which it claimed would provide its wireless email devices with technology that steers clear of a patent at the centre of a prolonged lawsuit.

The workaround is delivered as an update to the device's operating system and equips it with a special "US mode". If the judge grants an injunction against RIM, the vendor could guarantee its service by remotely flipping over all BlackBerry devices in the US.

However, the analysts questioned why RIM had not implemented the workaround immediately, which would put an end to the patent dispute.

This delay raises doubts about the seamlessness of the workaround. While RIM has said that the switch would cause no disruption to its service, the vendor did not say anything about third-party applications.

"It would be impossible for RIM to have tested the workaround with all its third-party partners," the report warned. "What the workaround really does is buy RIM time."

That time could either be used sit out a procedure in which the US Patent and Trademark Office seeks to invalidate the patent, or to reach a legal settlement.

RIM has previously offered about $500m to settle the case, but NTP turned down the offer and is hoping to get more.

See also:

RIM offers last minute NTP patent deal

Fourteen days left before dispute comes to court  10 Feb 2006

BlackBerry hopes crushed by Supreme Court

Patent saga takes a turn for the worst for RIM  25 Jan 2006

RIM adds Google/Apple apps to BlackBerry

Search giant's Local and Talk services, plus easier Mac synchronisation  13 Jan 2006

Like this story? Spread the news by clicking below:

 del.icio.us     Digg this     reddit!