BT's attempt to enforce a patent on internet hyperlinks has been thrown into fresh doubt by video footage of a 1968 research project.
BT's attempt to enforce a patent on internet hyperlinks has been thrown into fresh doubt by video footage of a 1968 research project.
The telco wanted US internet service providers to pay for their customers' rights to use hyperlinks in websites, the element of a web page a user clicks on to access another page or site.
However, the US-based Internet Patent News Service has discovered a website that hosts a film said to contain a demonstration of the hyperlink technology which pre-dates BT's claim by eight years.
The film involves a 90-minute presentation in 1968 by Douglas Englebart, of the Stanford Research Institute, that demonstrates the first mouse, and other innovations such as hyperlinks, which were to be elements of an online system he was working on.
The presentation occurred during a computer convention held in San Francisco, which was attended by about 1000 computer professionals, and can be seen online at http://sloan.stanford.edu/MouseSite/1968Demo.html
But BT said the patent dates back to the days of its Viewdata online services, including Prestel. The company said it applied for the patent with the US Patent Office in 1976, but didn't receive it until 1989.
The telco now wants money from organisations using hyperlinks until the patent expires in 2006. Its patents on hyperlinks in other countries have already expired.
A BT spokesman said that it was in the process of contacting US internet service providers to discuss licensing fees. "We're only asking to get what is rightfully ours," he said, adding that the process would continue through this month and November.
BT has hired intellectual property licensing firm QED, part of UK technology licensing company Scipher, to recover the unpaid fees arising from the many websites that use hyperlinks.
See also:
AltaVista said it is prepared to file suit in the next couple of months to protect patents it believes it has on indexing web pages, web spiders and other web search tools.
22 Jan 2001BT has begun its battle to recover licence fees from internet service providers, six months after first claiming to own a patent on the technology behind hyperlinks.
18 Dec 2000Franck Jeannin, the French chief executive of LinkGuard, a Maidenhead-based company that manages web links, talks about life in the UK, patents and the firm's new deal with Dell.
30 Nov 2000Software writers would be able to patent their programs in the UK for the first time under law changes being considered by the European Commission.
23 Oct 2000Interactive TV software vendor OpenTV has marched into a long running patent battle between Amazon.com and Barnes and Noble over one-click shopping, claiming that it was the first to patent the technology.
05 Oct 2000US patent law condemned as BT seeks substantial gain from hyperlink 'invention'.
10 Jul 2000BT has said it wants US Internet service providers to pay for their customers' rights to use hyperlinks in Web sites, because the British telco claims that it invented them.
29 Jun 2000BT's claim that it holds patents to internet-based hyperlink and hypertext technology - and more worryingly, that it intends to charge US ISPs to use it - has highlighted once again the absurdity of the hi-tech patent industry.
27 Jun 2000An industry user group has congratulated BT on its decision to pursue licence fees for the patent behind hyperlinks, the mainstay of web navigation, saying the telco's actions illustrate the absurdity of US software patent laws.
22 Jun 2000BT said today it wants US internet service providers to pay for their customers' rights to use hyperlinks in websites, because the British telco claims it invented them.
20 Jun 2000 All Ecommerce